Sheba vs. tuna | expatwoman.com
 

Sheba vs. tuna

226
Posts
EW NEWBIE
Latest post on 07 March 2012 - 11:16
OK, so I've spoiled my 2 cats who now turn their nose up at anything but Sheba. I had an idea that maybe even "people tuna" would be cheaper, and sure enough, some can be had for 3-4 dhs, for a bigger can than Sheba at 5 dhs. Is there anything wrong with feeding them tuna instead? And does it matter if it's the one in oil or the one in water?
372
Posts
EW EXPLORER
Latest post on 07 March 2012 - 11:18
OK, so I've spoiled my 2 cats who now turn their nose up at anything but Sheba. I had an idea that maybe even "people tuna" would be cheaper, and sure enough, some can be had for 3-4 dhs, for a bigger can than Sheba at 5 dhs. Is there anything wrong with feeding them tuna instead? And does it matter if it's the one in oil or the one in water? i feed mine tuna in spring water or brine- the one in oil will give them the runs so steer clear!
2357
Posts
EW EXPERT
Latest post on 07 March 2012 - 13:06
I would imagine that if a cat was fed canned tuna only, there might be a few risks... - high salt in some tuna would be bad for the kidneys - premium commercial foods are a true 'complete' diet so contain all of the nutrients they need (tuna only would have to be nutrient deficient) - some people worry about the mercury content in canned tuna...because of their small size Hg poisoning could be a much greater risk for cats I believe the latest thinking is that the ideal cat diet is premium canned food (I don't think "Sheba" is premium ;) ) and raw bones (chicken wings etc). Apparently poor quality dry food sticks to the teeth and can increase the risk of decay...
226
Posts
EW NEWBIE
Latest post on 07 March 2012 - 17:15
So what IS premium cat food then, where is found in Dubai, and dare I ask how much it costs? Little furry money-eaters..... (jk)
3860
Posts
EW MASTER
Latest post on 07 March 2012 - 17:19
To be honest lots of cat and dog foods are complete garbage and it's all about money making, why do you think most vets look like pet food suppliers. If your cat was in the wild what would it be eating? Hunting, killing and eating whatever it can get hold of, mice, rats, rabbits etc. Lots of foods have high water content. There's something to be said for raw, natural diets.
226
Posts
EW NEWBIE
Latest post on 07 March 2012 - 20:30
Cha-ching! So I should buy raw chicken now? This is getting more expensive by the minute! lol I draw the line at sourcing rodents, though... ;-) To be honest lots of cat and dog foods are complete garbage and it's all about money making, why do you think most vets look like pet food suppliers. If your cat was in the wild what would it be eating? Hunting, killing and eating whatever it can get hold of, mice, rats, rabbits etc. Lots of foods have high water content. There's something to be said for raw, natural diets.
3860
Posts
EW MASTER
Latest post on 07 March 2012 - 21:02
Cha-ching! So I should buy raw chicken now? This is getting more expensive by the minute! lol I draw the line at sourcing rodents, though... ;-) To be honest lots of cat and dog foods are complete garbage and it's all about money making, why do you think most vets look like pet food suppliers. If your cat was in the wild what would it be eating? Hunting, killing and eating whatever it can get hold of, mice, rats, rabbits etc. Lots of foods have high water content. There's something to be said for raw, natural diets. LOL if you went to the meat markets in say Deira and bought a load of frozen chicken that would last you ages, I bet it works out much cheaper than those ridiculous little tins of ponsy cat food. Some cats are just fussy, or become fussy. Mine has to have all his food liquidised as he has no teeth - disaster. <em>edited by Chocs01 on 07/03/2012</em>
2357
Posts
EW EXPERT
Latest post on 08 March 2012 - 18:14
To be honest lots of cat and dog foods are complete garbage and it's all about money making, why do you think most vets look like pet food suppliers. If your cat was in the wild what would it be eating? Hunting, killing and eating whatever it can get hold of, mice, rats, rabbits etc. Lots of foods have high water content. There's something to be said for raw, natural diets. Oh Chocs, I agree with you 100%. I followed the 'premium cat food' theory only because it can be hard to get a natural diet right without lots of research. BuckeyeD...if you do a little research on raw food diets for cats you'll find lots of resources. If you can buy in bulk, separate into meals and freeze, you'll save money too.
403
Posts
EW EXPLORER
Latest post on 11 March 2012 - 16:19
My mothers house cats have been fed John West tuna in sping water for over 7 years and they are fit and healthy! they have a few biscuit every day too. From being kittens they turned their noses up at everything else. She can't even change the brand of Tuna as they go on hunger strike. Best not to get the tuna in brine as this is salt water.
 

ON EXPATWOMAN TODAY