MIL driving me nuts!!!! | ExpatWoman.com
 

MIL driving me nuts!!!!

41
Posts
EW NEWBIE
Latest post on 11 April 2011 - 16:24

Thank God I don't have a gun! She is seriously stressing me out!
I know she means well BUT!
I just had my first baby 4 weeks ago and bless her she offered to help for which I am more than grateful.
DS was a dream baby in the first 2 weeks but after a growth spurge of sort he is finding it very difficult to settle and likes to be held and cradled but once he is asleep he goes on for a good few hours. It's true that he likes to nurse often and stays on for a long time but he is gaining weight and has a good nappy "output"

Anyhow, my MIL insist on me not having enough milk and she comments on every whimper as "ahhh, poor little thing he is hungry!!" making me feel totally ****!
And now she is going on about toping him up with formula so "poor little thing can grow" Arggghhhhh!!!!!!

190
Posts
EW NEWBIE
Latest post on 12 April 2011 - 19:18
I actually think that most of the problems we face during pregnancy and early motherhood are because we don't follow our instincts and trust our bodies enough. Formula isn't better than breastmilk... it's as close as scientists can get to a copy of breastmilk, but they can't get it spot on. It's a bit like suggesting that you ditch the fresh fruit and veg, and just go with supplements. Same nutrition, no? Well said. Second well said. Also glad to hear that I'm not the only one with MIL issues :)
3220
Posts
EW MASTER
Latest post on 12 April 2011 - 18:49
I actually think that most of the problems we face during pregnancy and early motherhood are because we don't follow our instincts and trust our bodies enough. Formula isn't better than breastmilk... it's as close as scientists can get to a copy of breastmilk, but they can't get it spot on. It's a bit like suggesting that you ditch the fresh fruit and veg, and just go with supplements. Same nutrition, no? Well said.
1861
Posts
EW EXPERT
Latest post on 12 April 2011 - 18:13
I wish I had been given advice 27 years ago from either my mum or my mother in law, but they had already passed away. Your assumption/guess is wrong and very ignorant. Do not know where some posters got their info from that it can harm the baby to alternate formula with breast feeding, but [b'>Please[/b'> tell me because several mums I know are doing this for different reasons, with approval of their mid wifes or gynecologists, but if it harms the baby they should be informed about this. It doesn't harm the baby, but can (and often does) harm your breastfeeding relationship with your baby, both in terms of potential nipple confusion, reduction in supply (by switching to a formula feed, your body thinks bubs no longer needs that feed, so reduces supply) and a general loss in confidence in the mum, which is the worst outcome of the 3, imo. It's very much a self-fulfilling prophesy, and once you start replacing milk feeds with formula feeds, it can be very challenging to switch back, both physically and mentally. I've found a lot of professionals (who should know better) are mis-informed and advise topping-up without much consideration and often a lack of judgement as to whether the child actually needs it for medical reasons. New mothers are constantly worried that they're doing The Right Thing or The Best Possible and so don't need to be undermined by others mis-informing them and urging them to go down routes they may not want, nor need to take. Thank you H.A.K. of course I know but I wanted to challenge those who just stated that it will do harm to your baby. And trusting your instincts as a new Mum is not enough, unfortunately I know this. The OP is probably right, her baby is doing well, but the fact she is posting is saying enough (to me) To be honest it doesn't do any harm to go for an extra check up and also have a look at the quality of the milk. This will work both ways, she will be able to confirm that everything is right to MIL, and that her feeling was correct. A boost for her confidence I think. I actually think that most of the problems we face during pregnancy and early motherhood are because we don't follow our instincts and trust our bodies enough. Formula isn't better than breastmilk... it's as close as scientists can get to a copy of breastmilk, but they can't get it spot on. It's a bit like suggesting that you ditch the fresh fruit and veg, and just go with supplements. Same nutrition, no?
68
Posts
EW NEWBIE
Latest post on 12 April 2011 - 17:59
I wish I had been given advice 27 years ago from either my mum or my mother in law, but they had already passed away. Your assumption/guess is wrong and very ignorant. Do not know where some posters got their info from that it can harm the baby to alternate formula with breast feeding, but [b'>Please[/b'> tell me because several mums I know are doing this for different reasons, with approval of their mid wifes or gynecologists, but if it harms the baby they should be informed about this. It doesn't harm the baby, but can (and often does) harm your breastfeeding relationship with your baby, both in terms of potential nipple confusion, reduction in supply (by switching to a formula feed, your body thinks bubs no longer needs that feed, so reduces supply) and a general loss in confidence in the mum, which is the worst outcome of the 3, imo. It's very much a self-fulfilling prophesy, and once you start replacing milk feeds with formula feeds, it can be very challenging to switch back, both physically and mentally. I've found a lot of professionals (who should know better) are mis-informed and advise topping-up without much consideration and often a lack of judgement as to whether the child actually needs it for medical reasons. New mothers are constantly worried that they're doing The Right Thing or The Best Possible and so don't need to be undermined by others mis-informing them and urging them to go down routes they may not want, nor need to take. Thank you H.A.K. of course I know but I wanted to challenge those who just stated that it will do harm to your baby. And trusting your instincts as a new Mum is not enough, unfortunately I know this. The OP is probably right, her baby is doing well, but the fact she is posting is saying enough (to me) To be honest it doesn't do any harm to go for an extra check up and also have a look at the quality of the milk. This will work both ways, she will be able to confirm that everything is right to MIL, and that her feeling was correct. A boost for her confidence I think.
231
Posts
EW NEWBIE
Latest post on 12 April 2011 - 17:58
@Crystil: oops sorry, thought you had quoted my post! Sleep deprivation combined with quiet simmering irritation makes me see things! :)
3220
Posts
EW MASTER
Latest post on 12 April 2011 - 17:19
Oh yes.. the old MIL. They tend to turn into monsters when you have your first. Mine drove me nuts too. All her knowledge of children was from the Dr Spock books. She always advised the opposite to what the pedi / doctors said. Real pain in the a**. I just put her back in her place and reminder her who the mother was. They do end up getting the message. Why are they like that? My MIL and I had a great relationship until my firstborn. Now I fantasize about kicking her off a cliff! I cant stand her now. Thankfully I have a supportive DH....
1861
Posts
EW EXPERT
Latest post on 12 April 2011 - 17:17
I wish I had been given advice 27 years ago from either my mum or my mother in law, but they had already passed away. Your assumption/guess is wrong and very ignorant. Do not know where some posters got their info from that it can harm the baby to alternate formula with breast feeding, but [b'>Please[/b'> tell me because several mums I know are doing this for different reasons, with approval of their mid wifes or gynecologists, but if it harms the baby they should be informed about this. It doesn't harm the baby, but can (and often does) harm your breastfeeding relationship with your baby, both in terms of potential nipple confusion, reduction in supply (by switching to a formula feed, your body thinks bubs no longer needs that feed, so reduces supply) and a general loss in confidence in the mum, which is the worst outcome of the 3, imo. It's very much a self-fulfilling prophesy, and once you start replacing milk feeds with formula feeds, it can be very challenging to switch back, both physically and mentally. I've found a lot of professionals (who should know better) are mis-informed and advise topping-up without much consideration and often a lack of judgement as to whether the child actually needs it for medical reasons. New mothers are constantly worried that they're doing The Right Thing or The Best Possible and so don't need to be undermined by others mis-informing them and urging them to go down routes they may not want, nor need to take.
68
Posts
EW NEWBIE
Latest post on 12 April 2011 - 16:57
Thank God I don't have a gun! She is seriously stressing me out! I know she means well BUT! I just had my first baby 4 weeks ago and bless her she offered to help for which I am more than grateful. DS was a dream baby in the first 2 weeks but after a growth spurge of sort he is finding it very difficult to settle and likes to be held and cradled but once he is asleep he goes on for a good few hours. It's true that he likes to nurse often and stays on for a long time but he is gaining weight and has a good nappy "output" Anyhow, my MIL insist on me not having enough milk and she comments on every whimper as "ahhh, poor little thing he is hungry!!" making me feel totally ****! And now she is going on about toping him up with formula so "poor little thing can grow" Arggghhhhh!!!!!! She might have a point, don't ignore her advise completely. your son was satisfied the first 2 weeks, after that he was on and off. Might be that your quality of breast milk has reduced. Can't harm the baby to give him a bottle in between and see how he reacts. [b'>[u'>Yikes are you serious? Who needs a mother in law with posts like this. Yes indeed it can harm a fully breastfed baby to give him a bottle to see how he reacts. Let me guess, you have never breastfed have you?[/b'>[/u'> I wish I had been given advice 27 years ago from either my mum or my mother in law, but they had already passed away. Your assumption/guess is wrong and very ignorant. Do not know where some posters got their info from that it can harm the baby to alternate formula with breast feeding, but [b'>Please[/b'> tell me because several mums I know are doing this for different reasons, with approval of their mid wifes or gynecologists, but if it harms the baby they should be informed about this.
142
Posts
EW NEWBIE
Latest post on 11 April 2011 - 23:11
@Crystil: I hope I am never a MIL like mine. While she is a nice human being, her level of insecurity is just unreal (read going through my things, stealing my cupboard keys, breaking into my cupboard, never asks to borrow my things- just tells me to give them to her, changes my instructions to my maid, nags nags nags and thinks everyone else is stupid and she knows what is best for DD to the extent that my maid cant stand talking to her anymore). After going through this rubbish, I will do my best to ensure I am a hands off MIL. @Fretty: your hormones ensure you have loads of milk for the first 6 weeks (or so I have read). Maybe your baby just went through a growth spurt and your body needs a few days to adjust. Just say "we'll see" and do what you want. @kinthecity-The problem is she lives with you...my MIL is the same - crazy crazy insecure. After all these years and the fact that she lives far away ( thank the lord for that or I would be a divorcee) I have learnt how to play a few mind games too.
379
Posts
EW EXPLORER
Latest post on 11 April 2011 - 22:47
@Crystil: I hope I am never a MIL like mine. While she is a nice human being, her level of insecurity is just unreal (read going through my things, stealing my cupboard keys, breaking into my cupboard, never asks to borrow my things- just tells me to give them to her, changes my instructions to my maid, nags nags nags and thinks everyone else is stupid and she knows what is best for DD to the extent that my maid cant stand talking to her anymore). After going through this rubbish, I will do my best to ensure I am a hands off MIL. Why you are directing your post at me I can't figure out. There are the MILs from h*ll, and there are also the mothers from h*ll, but it appears that it's always the in-laws that are the nightmares - be them MILs, FILs, BILs, SILs. Clearly your MIL has issues to the extreme. But I highly doubt that is the case with everyone who has to deal with those "horrible" MILs - who happen to be the mother of the man that they married, and those men in all probability don't have a clue how "horrible" their mothers are and how their wives have to put up with them. All of the women here will one day be a mother-in-law, and their turn will come. Some things never change and get passed on from generation to generation.
231
Posts
EW NEWBIE
Latest post on 11 April 2011 - 22:28
@Crystil: I hope I am never a MIL like mine. While she is a nice human being, her level of insecurity is just unreal (read going through my things, stealing my cupboard keys, breaking into my cupboard, never asks to borrow my things- just tells me to give them to her, changes my instructions to my maid, nags nags nags and thinks everyone else is stupid and she knows what is best for DD to the extent that my maid cant stand talking to her anymore). After going through this rubbish, I will do my best to ensure I am a hands off MIL. @Fretty: your hormones ensure you have loads of milk for the first 6 weeks (or so I have read). Maybe your baby just went through a growth spurt and your body needs a few days to adjust. Just say "we'll see" and do what you want.
369
Posts
EW EXPLORER
Latest post on 11 April 2011 - 22:00
Thank God I don't have a gun! She is seriously stressing me out! I know she means well BUT! I just had my first baby 4 weeks ago and bless her she offered to help for which I am more than grateful. DS was a dream baby in the first 2 weeks but after a growth spurge of sort he is finding it very difficult to settle and likes to be held and cradled but once he is asleep he goes on for a good few hours. It's true that he likes to nurse often and stays on for a long time but he is gaining weight and has a good nappy "output" Anyhow, my MIL insist on me not having enough milk and she comments on every whimper as "ahhh, poor little thing he is hungry!!" making me feel totally ****! And now she is going on about toping him up with formula so "poor little thing can grow" Arggghhhhh!!!!!! She might have a point, don't ignore her advise completely. your son was satisfied the first 2 weeks, after that he was on and off. Might be that your quality of breast milk has reduced. Can't harm the baby to give him a bottle in between and see how he reacts. Yikes are you serious? Who needs a mother in law with posts like this. Yes indeed it can harm a fully breastfed baby to give him a bottle to see how he reacts. Let me guess, you have never breastfed have you?
74
Posts
EW NEWBIE
Latest post on 11 April 2011 - 21:43
She might have a point, don't ignore her advise completely. your son was satisfied the first 2 weeks, after that he was on and off. Might be that your quality of breast milk has reduced. Can't harm the baby to give him a bottle in between and see how he reacts. Oh peuleeeese! Since when has any MiL been able to tell the nutritional composition of breastmilk just by staring at a newborn?! Besides, it [i'>can[/i'> harm your breastfeeding to "just" give the baby a bottle at 3 weeks old... and the mother's self-esteem. Fretty - you go girl. Nod and smile... and enjoy your baby! ;) Exactly what I was going to say! Just trust your instinct and your body. You'll be fine and so will be your LO. At 3 weeks comfort and cuddle sucking is just as important as feeding sucking. You DS feeding more more often does not have to mean that he's hungry due to "bad quality" breastmilk. Maybe he just needs a cuddle and reassurance. Especially now that he becomes more active and aware of his surroundings. Give it to him, no fear of spoiling him at this age.
1340
Posts
EW OLDHAND
Latest post on 11 April 2011 - 21:37
Just follow your OWN instincts. And enjoy your little one.
1861
Posts
EW EXPERT
Latest post on 11 April 2011 - 21:36
She might have a point, don't ignore her advise completely. your son was satisfied the first 2 weeks, after that he was on and off. Might be that your quality of breast milk has reduced. Can't harm the baby to give him a bottle in between and see how he reacts. Oh peuleeeese! Since when has any MiL been able to tell the nutritional composition of breastmilk just by staring at a newborn?! Besides, it [i'>can[/i'> harm your breastfeeding to "just" give the baby a bottle at 3 weeks old... and the mother's self-esteem. Fretty - you go girl. Nod and smile... and enjoy your baby! ;)
41
Posts
EW NEWBIE
Latest post on 11 April 2011 - 21:32
Thanks so much Ladies! Just knowing that I'm not alone with it makes such a difference. (typing with one hand, other is holding the peacefully napping DS after his feed-boob only ;-)
784
Posts
EW GURU
Latest post on 11 April 2011 - 21:13
Thank God I don't have a gun! She is seriously stressing me out! I know she means well BUT! I just had my first baby 4 weeks ago and bless her she offered to help for which I am more than grateful. DS was a dream baby in the first 2 weeks but after a growth spurge of sort he is finding it very difficult to settle and likes to be held and cradled but once he is asleep he goes on for a good few hours. It's true that he likes to nurse often and stays on for a long time but he is gaining weight and has a good nappy "output" Anyhow, my MIL insist on me not having enough milk and she comments on every whimper as "ahhh, poor little thing he is hungry!!" making me feel totally ****! And now she is going on about toping him up with formula so "poor little thing can grow" Arggghhhhh!!!!!! She might have a point, don't ignore her advise completely. your son was satisfied the first 2 weeks, after that he was on and off. Might be that your quality of breast milk has reduced. Can't harm the baby to give him a bottle in between and see how he reacts. what??? no!!!! be patient.. my b/milk was low at that point too..do a skin to skin contact with your LO... that is my advise from my doula and it worked!! *hugs*
68
Posts
EW NEWBIE
Latest post on 11 April 2011 - 21:10
Thank God I don't have a gun! She is seriously stressing me out! I know she means well BUT! I just had my first baby 4 weeks ago and bless her she offered to help for which I am more than grateful. DS was a dream baby in the first 2 weeks but after a growth spurge of sort he is finding it very difficult to settle and likes to be held and cradled but once he is asleep he goes on for a good few hours. It's true that he likes to nurse often and stays on for a long time but he is gaining weight and has a good nappy "output" Anyhow, my MIL insist on me not having enough milk and she comments on every whimper as "ahhh, poor little thing he is hungry!!" making me feel totally ****! And now she is going on about toping him up with formula so "poor little thing can grow" Arggghhhhh!!!!!! She might have a point, don't ignore her advise completely. your son was satisfied the first 2 weeks, after that he was on and off. Might be that your quality of breast milk has reduced. Can't harm the baby to give him a bottle in between and see how he reacts.
1340
Posts
EW OLDHAND
Latest post on 11 April 2011 - 20:39
I am loving this thread...........I must be the dream MIL..........I would never, ever, ever, even think about giving my DIL advice, she's a grown woman, she's smart, she's educated, she has all the same bits and instincts God gave to me - and all women......so why on earth should I stick my oar in? And, the weird thing is..........sometimes I feel guilty because I don't fulfil the stereotype? As for my DD........as I tell her, kiddo, I've done my time........now it's your turn. (But shout if you need help, tho.......not too often!)
26
Posts
EW NEWBIE
Latest post on 11 April 2011 - 20:09
Goodness - Reading this thread reminds of all the hassle my meddling MIL caused and she lives miles and miles away from us (thank god!)... DS is only 4 months old and she's already telling me to think about number 2! I must say, it used to upset me so much and whilst it still does, I have turned my time with her into a personal challenge. I smile and just nod or say non committal things like "that's interesting" or "let's see". Don't let her affect you too much (I know easier said than done) because that could eventually affect your milk supply if you are stressed / upset. And finally: DO NOT be coerced into topping up with formula. If you want to breastfeed, that's your choice and let a medical professional tell you that you don't have milk if that is actually the case! Grrr MILs so annoying the world over!
166
Posts
EW NEWBIE
Latest post on 11 April 2011 - 20:06
My MIL was a wonderful gran. Kept her opinions to herself and offered suggestions once in a while, at such intervals that it could never be misconstrued as butting in or being pushy but only as offers of genuine help. Always told me to rely on my mum as she herself did and said mothers' are the best support at that stage of a womans' life. She passed away recently, very recently and I miss her very much. When I hear some of you complain I can understand your frustration is genuine, as my sisters MIL was a horror story. I dont understand why the good ones pass on so early and the meanies live on and on !
369
Posts
EW EXPLORER
Latest post on 11 April 2011 - 20:03
I don't think its fair to say all MIL's are like that. I love my daughter in law and she is an awesome mother to my granddaughter and I tell her so frequently.
379
Posts
EW EXPLORER
Latest post on 11 April 2011 - 19:58
This thread brings up so many bad memories for me when I was living in Geneva and my MIL was next door. It just reminds me how we couldnt get along. Very stubborn generation So, this is the wise and wonderful generation that can't do no wrong is it? Are you saying that MIL had problems with you, but you didn't have any with her and it was one-sided? Your first mistake was living so close to her.
1340
Posts
EW OLDHAND
Latest post on 11 April 2011 - 19:58
Ahhh, to think that one day your daughter/daughter in law will be saying pretty much the same about you!!! You took the words out of my mouth............and "that" generation someone referred to ......hardly belong to the Stone Age........how old are these dreadful dinosaurs? 50's, 60's? Hardly raised in the dark ages! Unlike my MIL of course.........I was a very modern young Mum in 1969 ;);) I was a "hip" mom in '67. If you will excuse me now, I have to throw more wood in the stove and get the fire going to get dinner started. I also have to fill my lanterns with some oil as the lights are dimming - or is that my eyesight? LOL That's told the youngun's!!!
232
Posts
EW NEWBIE
Latest post on 11 April 2011 - 19:56
Fretty, you had me at "thank god I don't have a gun";) You sound so secure and grounded in your role as a new mum and have a good sense of humour about it... You're gonna be just fine..;) I like JoyceB's advice. Keep her busy and involved without it infringing on your parenting. As for the top up feeding, she probably is just dying to feed the baby.. bless her, she loves her grandchild and this probably brings back magical memories for her. Good luck and keep to your guns. Enjoy your beautiful baby;)
379
Posts
EW EXPLORER
Latest post on 11 April 2011 - 19:54
Ahhh, to think that one day your daughter/daughter in law will be saying pretty much the same about you!!! You took the words out of my mouth............and "that" generation someone referred to ......hardly belong to the Stone Age........how old are these dreadful dinosaurs? 50's, 60's? Hardly raised in the dark ages! Unlike my MIL of course.........I was a very modern young Mum in 1969 ;);) I was a "hip" mom in '67. If you will excuse me now, I have to throw more wood in the stove and get the fire going to get dinner started. I also have to fill my lanterns with some oil as the lights are dimming - or is that my eyesight? LOL
213
Posts
EW NEWBIE
Latest post on 11 April 2011 - 19:49
This thread brings up so many bad memories for me when I was living in Geneva and my MIL was next door. It just reminds me how we couldnt get along. Very stubborn generation
1340
Posts
EW OLDHAND
Latest post on 11 April 2011 - 19:40
Ahhh, to think that one day your daughter/daughter in law will be saying pretty much the same about you!!! You took the words out of my mouth............and "that" generation someone referred to ......hardly belong to the Stone Age........how old are these dreadful dinosaurs? 50's, 60's? Hardly raised in the dark ages! Unlike my MIL of course.........I was a very modern young Mum in 1969 ;);)
5400
Posts
EW MASTER
Latest post on 11 April 2011 - 19:37
I emphatize and sympathize. My MIL is here right now and I could just ************** (fill in the blank). Just ignore it and do what you want to. I do and though it kills me, confronting her wont change her mind. Frankly, if you ask me that generation has no respect for the medical profession and think they know EVERYTHING about everything esp raising children. A certain generation has no respect for anyone younger than they are, including their own female children ;) You cannot imagine the garbage my mother throws at me (I'm 55, I'm the way I am because of how she brought me up and I didn't want to do the same to my own child ;) ).
379
Posts
EW EXPLORER
Latest post on 11 April 2011 - 19:33
Ahhh, to think that one day your daughter/daughter in law will be saying pretty much the same about you!!!
 
 

ON EXPATWOMAN TODAY